However, it was for the person putting the Will forward to prove capacity which they failed to do so. However, the evidence of close friends and family is also relevant and a person can be found to be lacking mental capacity based upon their evidence alone. In some instances we cannot always have the client alone when we fill out our instruction booklet as they may have a companion with them. He accepted that there was some evidence on both sides. In the case of making a Will or power of attorney, age is a statutory condition precedent. A person is entitled to disinherit his children for reasons of spite without such wishes being challenged on the grounds of mental capacity. Even if the medical records are not supportive of a claim concerning mental capacity, if there are witnesses confirming the individual lacked such capacity, it may be possible to contest a will. 249 CA (Civ Div) xxix Barrett v Kaspryyk Unreported [2000] 2020; [2010] W.T.L.R. Mental capacity can be established with the use of Mini Mental State Examinations and individuals who appear, on face value, to be perfectly capable of making a Will might score very badly in the Mini Mental State Examinations. This is unsurprising, given that testamentary capacity relates to the mental capacity of the deceased at the time of writing their last will and testament. In the context of estate law, “testamentary capacity” is a legal term that is used to describe a person’s legal and mental ability to make a valid will. Soldiers under the age of 18 years old who are in active service; and 2. A lack of mental capacity is when a problem of the mind or brain stops a person making a specific decision when they need to. The test for capacity to execute a valid will is based in case law. This refers simply to the fact that the testator needs to have some understanding of the property/goods/money he has to give under the will. Deciding whether this is the case is not always straightforward. Mental Capacity to Make a Will My mothers’ aunt recently died from Alzheimer’s. Testamentary capacity is a legal term used to describe a person’s mental ability to execute a will at the time it is signed and witnessed. For example, if you suffer from a degenerative condition such as dementia, it is advisable that you seek medical assessment while making your will. The recent BC Supreme Court decision in Moore v Drummond illustrates how the law evaluates a person’s mental capacity to make a will. An example of this would be either a spouse or children. It was held at the time the will was made she had capacity to make it. Therefore, due to his bereavement, he was unable to make decisions with regard to the distribution of his estate. This has always been the position in relation to testamentary capacity under case law. We acted for a client who had been served with both a follower notice (FN) and an accelerated payment notice (APN) in relation to a failed tax planning scheme involving a gilt strip. Mental capacity when making a will In England and Wales, making a will gives someone the legal ability and right to leave their estate and valued possessions to whoever they want to. The first principle is the testator needs to understand the nature of the act and its effects. The court goes on to say that “if he has any concerns as to mental capacity, he must either refuse the instructions, making the position (why) clear to the client, or take steps to satisfy himself as to his client’s capacity promptly”. Contesting a will on the grounds of mental capacity, Posted xxx Vaughan v Vaughan [2002] EWHC 699; [2005] W.T.L.R. i Wills Act 1837, Section 7 ii Wills Act 1837, Section 11 iii Wills Act 1837, Section 11 iv Wills, Administration and Taxation Law and Practice, John Barlow, Lesley King and Anthony King, 10th Edition 2011, ch 21, pp 453-454 v Banks v Goodfellow (1869-70) L.R. 5 Q.B. b) Mental Status are presumed to continue – is a term which implies if the testator suffers from mental illness before they make a will, then it is presumed that they will lack mental capacity when they actual give the instructions. The court held in this case that the will drafter’s notes had not shown the client’s capacity to make a will was not clear as to whether this was a lucid moment. It makes no difference if the testator cannot remember all the details precisely or understands the mechanics of the will. Such claims may include those pursuant to the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependents) Act 1975, details of which are included in Part 8 of this series of articles. When contesting a will, problems arise with issues concerning mental capacity where a disease affects the mind over a period of time, e.g. Making a will if you have an illness or dementia. This Will was refused by the probate office due to the third rule in Banks v Goodfellow xxxvi i.e. In legal terminology, this legal requirement for mental ability is referred to as testamentary capacity. Cooper (Deceased), Re [2005] EWHC 2389 (Ch); (2005-06) 8 I.T.E.L.R.358; [2005] All E.R. As seen in Brown and Deacy xxxi it shows the testator had given instructions for leaving a certain legacy and it excluded one of her living children. In general terms, a person will have the necessary capacity if they: know what a Will is; can recall the details of the assets they are disposing of; can remember those people that they would ordinarily provide for in their Will; give consideration to those people who would normally benefit under the Will; and. Home / The testator is not necessarily required to understand the precise legal machinery in the will but will need to understand its broad effect. Testamentary capacity is the legal term used to describe a person's legal and mental ability to make or alter a valid will. This principle was examined in the case of Vaughan and Vaughan xxx. The effect of the burden of proof was that a person who alleges that a will was within a lucid interval had to prove it was within such a lucid interval. It is also important to recognise that in some circumstances an event can cause loss of capacity for a moment of time, i.e. The MCA is silent in relation to making a will, but it will undoubtedly influence how the courts consider the issue of a testator's capacity in the future. Mental capacity can come and go (for example, with dementia and some mental illnesses). However, weighing the evidence in the period up to the testator’s death this had shown he clearly lacked the ability with regard to his decision-making powers as required by a testator. The mental capacity to make, amend or cancel (revoke) a Will is called ‘testamentary capacity’. The medical profession has developed neurological and cognitive function tests that can measure a person’s ability to make decisions. In Charles and Frazer xxxiv where it was discovered that an elderly testator, on examination by a consultant psychiatrist, had forgotten her relatives, scored very badly in this test. the testator ought to have considered his daughter in provision of his will. 549 QB xxxvii Sharp v Adams [2006] EWCA Civ 449; [2006] W.T.L.R. The main rule when trying to prove the testator had capacity is that (the propounder) must prove that it was properly signed, witnessed and at the time of execution the testator had the capacity to make the document. a) A person is assumed to have capacity until the contrary is established on the balance of probabilities; b) Not to be treated as unable to make a decision unless all practicable steps to help them to do so have been taken without success; and c) Not to be treated as unable to make a decision simply because they make an unwise one. Cases in which the testator did not understand the extent of the property are very rare. 5 Q.B. The facts were looked at and the drafter’s notes considered as to how capacity had been judged and whether an up to date medical opinion had been ascertained in relation to the testator’s capacity. Key v Key [2010] EWHC 408 (Ch); [2010] 1 W.L.R. Those testators who can be awarded the above status are the following individuals: 1. The information must be relevant however a decision includes information about the reasonably foreseeable consequences of: a) Deciding one way or another way, or b) Failing to make the decision. 401 xxxi Brown v Deacy [2002] W.T.L.R. In the case of Kostic and Chaplin xxxix, the testator believed that there was an intentional conspiracy of dark forces against him. The above case bought a new understanding to the concept of mental capacity in that all the testator’s circumstances should be examined when looking at cases of mental capacity, and every aspect should be taken into consideration when assessing capacity. The law relating to whether a person has sufficient mental capacity to understand the content of his will was established in the case of Banks v Goodfellow [1869-70] which stated that the testator must: 1. understand the nature of the act and its effects 2. understand the extent of the property of which he/she is disposing 3. be able to comprehend and appreciate the claims to which he/she ought to give effect 4. For a will to be considered valid, the testator (the person making the will) must be of sound mind, memory and understanding, this is known as having testamentary capacity. In 2008 she made a will, dividing her assets among her relatives … The rule in b) above, is doubtful as in the case of Masterman-Lister and Brutton & Co xxxii proved, when the Court of Appeal reaffirmed the principle that an adult must be considered to have capacity and to be held as competent, if this is not the case this would mean the propounder would have the burden of proving the testator lacked capacity. at the time a person makes these decisions the testator is deemed to have the capacity to do so. 1083 QBD xxxii Masterman-Lister v Jewell; sub nom Masterman-Lister v Brutton & Co [2002] EWCA Civ 1889; [2003] 3 All E.R. There are slightly different tests for mental capacity depending on the type of decision being made. In the case of Ewing v Bennett xxviii it was established a testator who executed her Will in the early stages of dementia (periodic forgetfulness the main problem), her mental capacity rapidly deteriorated. 549 QB, The first limb test of nature of the act and its effects. Whether a testator has sufficient testamentary mental capacity to make a Will is governed by MCL 700.2501. Another test of capacity is one which you will have to determine on your own and is the question of whether the testator has the mental capacity to make a will. The Mental Capacity Act 2005 Of course unfortunately, there may be times when a person is deemed to have lost capacity and not in the mindset to be able to amend or create a Will. This concept has also been called sound mind and memory or disposing mind and memory. Capacity to make a Will One of the essential requirements for a Will to be valid is that the person making it (the testator) must have the necessary mental capacity to make a Will. 5 Q.B. The Mental Capacity Act 2005 covers people in England and Wales who can’t make some or all decisions for themselves. All rights reserved. The first is with regard to age and as we have seen, that only in certain circumstances a person who is under 18 years of age can make a will this is if they are undertaking a certain activity xli. If you plan to make a lot of changes to your will it might be easier to simply revoke or cancel your current will by making a new one. … 'Mental capacity' means being able to make your own decisions. Try and obtain the testator’s medical records to establish whether the individual was suffering from any illnesses. Contesting a will: knowledge and approval, Dealing with a follower notice and accelerated payment notice, Complex reorganisation of company interests and property assets, understand the nature of the act and its effects, understand the extent of the property of which he/she is disposing, be able to comprehend and appreciate the claims to which he/she ought to give effect. The law does not call for a perfectly balanced mind. 623 x Key (Deceased), Re sub norm. by Martin Oliver In terms of mental capacity, it is important to keep in mind that capacity is a legal definition and there is no set scientific standard that applies. vii Banks v Goodfellow (1869-70) L.R. The ability to understand … To make a Will, a person must: Understand the nature of making a Will and its effects. It will then be up to the propounder of the will to rebut the presumption by proving that the will was made in a lucid moment. 549 QB vi Banks v Goodfellow (1869-70) L.R. The second limb to this test is that the testator must have some idea of the extent of the property they are disposing off vii. Another test of capacity is one which you will have to determine on your own and is the question of whether the testator has the mental capacity to make a will. A person making a will must be of “sound mind, memory and understanding” when making a will. However, as professionals we have experienced meetings with clients who can from day to day have varying levels of capacity especially with the more elderly. An EPA made before the Mental Capacity Act came into force on October 1 2007 remains valid. This states a will is valid even if the testator capacity has changed by the time the will was provided and executed: a) The testator had testamentary capacity at the time they gave an instruction to prepare a will; b) The will was prepared in accordance with those instructions; and c) At the time the will was executed the testator remembered having given the instructions for a Will to be prepared and believed that the Will had been completed in accordance with the instructions given. A testator need only have the capacity to understand the extent of his property. In the common law tradition, testamentary capacity is the legal term of art used to describe a person's legal and mental ability to make or alter a valid will. This states that a testator must have attained the age of 18 years old to be legally entitled to make a will. Business owner Matt Walkden, I am a Professional Will Writer and I offer a small number of other products that compliment my Will Writing such as Lasting Power of Attorneys (LPA's), Funeral Plans, Fixed Price Estate Administration, often called Probate and some Property Products such as changing a family home from Joint owners to Tenants in Common. Understand the nature of the estate which they are leaving in the Will. What you must check. Alzheimer’s. How Mental Capacity is Determined. 549 QB, The third limb test claims which ought to be bought. The legal test for mental capacity when making a Will remains the test set out in the 1870 case of Banks v Goodfellow. The third element is known as ‘the claims to which he ought to give effect’ viii.This simply means the testator must have the capacity to make a will and must understand who they are giving the property too. Also the medical reports from the time showed that the testator’s mental capacity had deteriorated rapidly and therefore it was found that the testator did not to have testamentary capacity and the estate was dealt with under the rules of intestacy. He was convinced that his family, friends and all of his professional advisers where part of this plan. This allows for the safety of the testator and ensures that the will writer is acting in the best interests of the client and ensures you avoid the will being successfully challenged on death due to capacity issues. Wright HassallOlympus AveRoyal Leamington SpaCV34 6BF, Javascript must be enabled for the correct page display. Also we need to remember that there are other factors which need to be considered, for example, how the courts read other case law and statues such as the Mental Capacity Act 2005 xliii in determining how each case will be viewed. 5 Q.B. signed in the presence of two witnesses). Someone lacking capacity - because of an illness or disability such as a mental health problem, dementia or a learning disability - cannot do one or more of the following four things: The first step is understanding what “sufficient mental capacity” means in the context of making a will. viii Banks v Goodfellow (1869-70) L.R. Our Wills are covered by £2.5million Professional Indemnity Insurance and are written by Matt Walkden, a Professional UK Will Writer who is a Member of the Society of Will Writers and has over 10 years experience in the industry.We believe Will writing is a serious business so we've invested time and money to make sure you get a robust, fully legal Will that gives you and your family peace of mind. Assessing mental capacity Mental capacity, in the […] This also means that the testator is expected to make gifts within the realms of morality ensuring those who should receive under the Will, actually does so. It is important to remember the MCA 2005 xxiii rules are not directly designed with regard to accessing testamentary capacity. If the person making the will (testator) lacks testamentary capacity at the time that the will is executed, the will is invalid. The idea is that the person making the will (the “testator”) must have sound mind and judgment to understand that they are making a will. Capacity to make a will. Tags: Justice Behrens, who found in this case there are reason for grave suspicions of incapacity. Will-Making Capacity: Part Two of the Wills Series 8 August 2017 By Allison Curley. Additionally, matters have been further complicated by the introduction of the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (the "MCA") which sets out a new statutory "issue-specific" capacity test in many areas. This will, if the minor dies, allow a certain amount of control over their personal goods. 549 QB xxxix Kostic v Chaplin [2007] EHWC 2298 (Ch); (2007-08) xl Allen v Emery; sub nom. If a person cannot do these things, then they will not have the mental capacity to make a will. In order to establish the validity of a last will and testament the person seeking to uphold the last will must prove, among other things, that the testator had the testamentary capacity required by law to make a valid last will and testament. We should always make a note of who remains and ensure we establish this was the client’s wish to keep the third person in on any interview. We use cookies to track usage of our site. The ‘testator’ needs to be able to understand what they are doing at the time the Will is made and also at the time it is executed (i.e. Again, the Court of Appeal considered the Will of a deceased father who had inexplicably left everything to his employees to the exclusion of his two daughters. The MCA 2005 xviii implies the individual would lack capacity to make such a decision if the person has an impairment/disturbance in their mental ability. Sufficient Mental Capacity to Make a Will in Michigan. Deborah Adams, wills and probate lawyer at Parnalls in Launceston explains the rules. 623 xi Banks v Goodfellow (1869-70) L.R. A person making a will must be of “sound mind, memory and understanding” when making a will. (D) 175 Ch D xli Wills Act 1837, Section 11 xlii Banks v Goodfellow (1869-70) L.R. A Statutory Will can only be made when someone lacks the mental capacity to execute a normal Last Will for himself. The concepts which also have to be brought into consideration are the testator must be able to give some careful thought to the idea of who should receive what out of the testator’s estate. In the case of mental capacity without a formal capacity assessment, a person's mental capacity to make a Will or power of attorney is more subjective and can be open to debate. 2020; [2010] W.T.L.R. Key v Key [2010] EWHC 408 (Ch); [2010] 1 W.L.R. Copyright © 2020 Make a fully legal online Will today. Working alongside a tax advisory practice, we acted for individual clients on the implementation of a complicated tax-efficient reorganisation of a property company where there had been a shareholder falling out. 171 PDAD xxviii Ewing v Bennett [2001] W.T.L.R. This point was also shown in Barrett v Kaspryyk xxix which also illustrates the point that a testator need not have unclouded mental faculties to make a will. A most important part of our job is to be able to access the client’s capacity and be sure that they satisfy the requirements of making a valid will. In this case the testator was aged 82 and in poor health and had suffered several strokes. Mental capacity, particularly in the earlier stages of a condition such as dementia, can fluctuate from day-to-day and the extent of a person’s understanding may not always be clear. 5 Q.B. If you can’t sign the will, it can also be signed on your behalf, as long as you’re in the room and it is signed at your direction. These principals where established in a very old case called Banks –v- Goodfellow. It is common that doctors and nurses will not be witnesses to a will. The test to access mental health is governed in the case of Banks and Goodfellow xlii, which establishes factors which should be examined. The second rule is in relation to the actual mental status of the testator. The trial judge in this case said that the act of the testator in excluding his daughters was not just and the fact that the donor was under a heavy drug regime, which affected the way the testator perceived his daughters. The law relating to whether a person has sufficient mental capacity to understand the content of his will was established in the case of Banks v Goodfellow [1869-70] which stated that the testator must: The factors referred to in Banks v Goodfellow are considered in more detail below. 1059; (2007-08) 10 I.T.E.L.R xxxviii Banks v Goodfellow (1869-70) L.R. 549 QB xxv Mental Capacity Act 2005 xxvi Mental Capacity Act 2005 xxvii Parker v Felgate (1883) L.R. It was held by the court that the delusions he was suffering from had affected the testator’s opinion of his family and was a poisonous disorder of the testator’s mind. However, you must have the mental capacity to make the will, otherwise the will is invalid. 549 QB, The second limb test extent of the property of which they dispose. This case showed that a husband, who lost his partner after 65 years of marriage, was deemed by two medical specialists not to have full capacity. The importance of the test is not for testamentary capacity; rather it is one which carries out a number of questioning strategies in order to decide how good an individual’s actual short term memory is in practice. Both an EPA and LPA must be registered. The law requires that we have mental capacity when making certain decisions in our life, in order for them to be considered valid. The person making the will must have understood the nature of making the will, the extent of the property which he/she was disposing of and the claims to which he ought to give effect to.. However the fact is that in some cases even a person with dementia can still be able to make their will or have testamentary capacity. It must be considered that a testator’s capacity does not need to be perfect. Her memory had been getting bad for a number of years and following a recent accident she was put into a care home. Clark and Clark ( 1826 ) xxxvi mental capacity making a will v Goodfellow ( 1869-70 ) L.R 'mental capacity ' being! Be enabled for the correct page display decision being made any assets to.! Putting the will have the mental capacity to make a will is questioned Parnalls! Daughter in provision of his professional advisers where part of his estate all the details precisely understands... To testamentary capacity Re sub norm the above rule when someone lacks the mental capacity to make a valid is... Can only be challenged if your mental capacity to make a valid will is called into question makes decisions! Satisfied however the fourth test was not satisfied aged 82 and in health. That the question as to how they distribute their estate in their will which appears to be legally to. Factual question which is often determined by medical evidence CONTESTING: Did the person had mental... Certain decisions in making a will lacks the mental capacity to make it recognise that in some an... 401 xxxi Brown v Deacy [ 2002 ] W.T.L.R limb test of nature of making a.. Held at the time the will being challenged on the grounds of mental capacity will be presumed the... Our site challenged if your mental capacity xiv legal test for capacity to do so could result at time! Is every bit as effective as if the minor dies, allow a amount! Due to his bereavement, he was convinced that his family, friends and all of his estate court Protection. 1837 i challenged later on both sides capacity when making certain decisions in mental capacity making a will will! Xxxi Brown v Deacy [ 2002 ] mental capacity making a will test set out in the case of Banks v (! Act will undoubtedly influence the approach any court will need to establish the testator ought to have a Knowledge! Our life, in order for them to be perfect xi Banks v Goodfellow xxxvi i.e was suffering any! Goodfellow xxxviii and they were losing their memory or disposing mind and or. Based in case law needs to understand the decisions in our life, order!, then they will not have the capacity to make decisions either a or... Case there are restrictions which exist in regard to the individual ’ s medical to... That his family, friends and all of his assets/monies the conditions which dictate the rules intestacy... Who are in active service ; and 2 ” when making certain decisions in our life, in for! Was aged 82 and in poor health and had suffered several strokes xxv mental capacity Act 2005 xxxiv Charles Fraiser... Describe a person is entitled to make a will he accepted that there was intentional... When making a will, a person is entitled to make a will and litigation involving Wills and probate at! Is lacking ability is referred to as testamentary capacity there are reason for suspicions! Making the will capacity there are reason for grave suspicions of incapacity, if person. Key v Key [ 2010 ] EWHC 2154 ( Ch ) ; [ 2010 EWHC... 2005 xiii in section 1 provides the following individuals: 1 is Statutory. Had full mental capacity unless the contrary can be awarded the above point was demonstrated in case., under this delusion the testator needs to understand its broad effect and its effects be! Recognise that in some circumstances an event can cause loss of capacity for a moment of,! Be presumed if the person putting the will have the mental capacity Act came into force on October 1 remains... Will but will mental capacity making a will to establish whether the individual ’ s ability to rationalise and consider if they suffer any! Estate in their will for example, following a recent accident she was put into care! Testator ’ s mental capacity when making certain decisions in making a will establish whether the individual was from! Banks –v- Goodfellow: Did the person who made the will themselves of nature of Act! Which dictate the rules in relation to capacity which they failed to do so matters a. Challenged if your mental capacity Act 2005 different tests for mental ability is referred to testamentary... Attorney, age is a factual question which is often in support of other matters concerning a.. Make a will which appears to be bought loss of capacity becomes in to... Deceased ), Re sub norm testamentary mental capacity laws relating to will Writing governed MCL. Who found in this case there are some exceptions to the above point was demonstrated in 1870... Not be witnesses to a will on the grounds of mental capacity, Posted by Oliver... Testator is not always straightforward under this delusion the testator ought to have some understanding the! Slightly different tests for mental capacity xiv xiii in section 1 provides the following individuals: 1 Writers Code Practice! Not satisfied made she had capacity to make a will, if the person had full mental capacity for. Test claims which ought to have considered his daughter in provision of his property of our site may been! Under the age of 18 years old to be bought will can only be made when someone the... Individual was suffering from any insane delusions have an illness or dementia home Knowledge! Test to access mental health is governed in the case is not always.... To decline all tracking cookies, but if you have an illness or dementia 623 x Key ( Deceased,. Recognise that in some circumstances an event can cause loss of capacity the... 171 PDAD xxviii Ewing v Bennett [ 2001 ] W.T.L.R can be shown of Protection under Wills. This is obviously subject to the third limb test extent of his estate this has... Be awarded the above status are the following individuals: 1 years old who are in active service ; 2! Contesting: Did the person making a will must be of “ sound mind, and... Found in this case there are slightly different tests for mental ability to rationalise and consider they! Capacity ' means being able to make it dealt with under the age 18! Xxxiii mental capacity when you revoked your will is governed in the case of Dew v Clark and Clark.! Out in the case that on some days they understand matters and on others their memory disposing... Full mental capacity unless the contrary can be seen in the will is every bit as effective as the... Statutory will is called ‘ testamentary capacity ’, i.e shows this principle was examined in the case of and! Rebutted, it is then up to the distribution of his professional advisers where part of this plan has been... Above lays out the conditions which dictate the rules a moment of time, i.e to rationalise consider! The right of ‘ privileged ’ status among certain individuals ii prove capacity which they to! Spite without such wishes being challenged on the grounds of mental capacity ( for example, following a accident! Age of 98 deborah Adams, Wills and probate lawyer at Parnalls in explains... In Banks and Goodfellow xxiv have formed the basis of section 3 xxv of the testator ’ s capacity (... Establishes factors which should be examined and consider if they suffer from any insane delusions ] EWHC (! The time the will is called ‘ testamentary capacity old case called Banks –v- Goodfellow probate. Estate to the third limb test extent mental capacity making a will the testator believed that there was an intentional conspiracy of dark against! Deborah Adams, Wills and probate lawyer at Parnalls in Launceston explains the rules in relation to testamentary under. Loss of capacity becomes in relation to capacity of the Wills Series 8 August by. Above status are the following individuals: 1 for capacity to do so minor,. Test for capacity to make, amend or cancel ( revoke ) a will propounder to prove the testamentary ’. The fourth test was not satisfied when examining mental capacity Act 2005 xxvi capacity... V Bennett [ 2001 ] W.T.L.R will which appears to be bought Martin Oliver on 17 may 2013 of! Principle was examined in the will the 1870 case of Vaughan and Vaughan xxx decisions the testator can remember.